Type of site
|Registration||Required subscription to view site content|
|Launched||July 2nd, 2014|
The original goal was set at $30,000. During the campaign, Coleman and Martin Thomas continued to podcast and update fans on the growing total. On the last night, they held a 24-hour live stream with guests and fans stopping by for support. At the end of the stream, the final amount given was $133,860.
As a result, doubletoasted.com was created, and launched on July 2, 2014.
On October 17, 2019, in a video posted on the site's YouTube page, it was announced that Double Toasted would move to Twitch in November, in a deal that would have the site's main shows move to the platform, with the exception of other content, that would continue to be on the site.
Podcasts and segments
This section needs additional citations for verification. (September 2016)
Unlike Spill.com, Double Toasted features both audio and video for every show. Since the site's launch in July 2014, there have been several podcasts started - each with a different cast.
The Sunday Service
Korey Coleman and Martin Thomas sit down for some free-form conversation, the weekend box office, a recap of the week's highlighted stories, and take emails and calls from the audience.
The show occasionally features interviews and appearances from members of the community, a.k.a. 'Toasties'.
Notable guests include:
What Up, Son!
Korey Coleman, Oz Greene Jr., who skypes from New York, and Korey's wife, Miss Mia, host this segment. The three talk about the "Free Form Foolishness" in the world and diverge into a variety of topics mixed with casual conversation. The show was initially an audio-only show, but has since moved to video.
The Weekly Roast and Toast
Korey Coleman, Martin Thomas and (sometimes) Billy Brooks look at the latest trailers released, comment on submitted news stories of the week, followed by emails and phone calls. They host an additional segment where they review older bad movies
- Correll Bufford
The Movie Review Extravaganza
Korey Coleman and Martin Thomas share their opinions on the latest releases. People have the chance to win a prize in the trivia game 'Martin gets a gold star!'. Occasionally they will bring a guest to help review the film. The show's introductory song is "Revolution World Crazy" by Panacea.
Korey Coleman and Chris Herman discuss video game news and entertainment stories, review games and movies, and answer fan questions on Double Toasted's Twitch show. They also occasionally play games.
The Daily Double Talk
Korey Coleman and Christian Torres talk about news in entertainment. Originally an audio only podcast with Korey and Tommy.
After giving their thoughts on the movie, each critic gives a rating based on how much of your time and money are worth spending on it. Each rating can have a high/low variation. The ratings are the same ones carried over from Spill.com. From highest to lowest, they are:
|BETTER THAN SEX!||A rating withheld by the crew, this film is excellent, and pushes the boundaries of cinema as an art form.|
|Full Price||A very enjoyable film which is worth paying full price for in the cinema.|
|Matinee||Worth seeing in the cinema, but not worth paying full price for, or at least during the initial theatrical run.|
|Rental||Can be enjoyed, but still has a variety of flaws. This is worth waiting paying very little to see after the theatrical release.|
|Some Ol' Bullshit!||The crew recommend against paying any money to see this film, and has very little that redeems it.|
|F*** YOU!||The crew actively recommends against seeing this film at all. This rating is typically given when a critic is angered or offended by a film's content, and indicates that it has absolutely no redeeming qualities.|
Once the review has been posted on the site, members of the community can give a one to five star rating, depending on what they thought of the film.
Korey also hosts interview segments separate from the other shows.
- Ricardo González, Michael Guasch and Toni Calderon from The Gentleman Driver
- Mary Lynn Rajskub
- Steve Johnson
- Xavier Neal-Burgin
- Lisa Henson (episode was not aired live at the request of Henson)
- Jhonen Vasquez
- Keith David
- Alexandre O. Philippe
- William Conlin
- Andrew Shea
- Sergio Pablos
- Sam Sawyer creator of S.A.L.E.M.
- Jerry Minor
- Rob Paulsen
- Bruce W. Smith
- J.D. and Pilar Witherspoon.
- Chris Stuckmann
- Doug Walker
The Casual Call-In Show
Korey Coleman, Danielle Dallaire and Ray Villarreal answered fan questions through phone calls, Skype and emails. The show was initially released every Monday, but ceased in February 2017 due to low viewership.
The Spoiler Show
William Valle discussed movies in depth. Korey Coleman was featured as a guest, but after one episode, which was heavily criticized, the show was immediately terminated.
The Double Dribble
Ray Villareal and co-host Chase Arthur discussed sports and other extracurricular activities in a free-form discussion. The show was canceled in June 2017 when Chase left the site and Ray chose not to continue it. Special guest includes:
- Mia Khalifa (multiple occasions)
The High Score
Korey Goodwin and T.J. Manatsa (formally Patrick Girts) discussed the latest video game news, followed by a playthrough of games chosen by the community. The show was released every Saturday and had its last show on May 26, 2018.
Toast to Toast
William Valle hosted a short form talk show where he focused on a specific topic related to politics, social issues, or popular culture. He also features a special guest, usually someone from the crew, every episode. The show was released every other Friday. It was canceled because Valle felt the show was repetitive to the already existing shows. Valle would later bring Toast to Toast's format to a new show called Night Class on his own website Camel Moon.
Sammy Ain't Seen Sh*t
A spin-off segment from the Weekly Roast and Toast. This segment focuses on film school graduate Sammy González, who along with Chris Herman (formally Ian Butcher), take a look at important or classic films that they had not seen until recently. The show was released every Thursday. It ended after Sammy chose to leave the site.
What's in the Box
DJ Milez and Comic book writer, Christian Torres talk about television shows and dive into TV and other related news. The show abruptly came to an end on August 8, 2019.
|Korey Coleman||Owner and creator of Doubletoasted.com, film critic, actor, voice actor, and animator. Also known as Captain Matinee due to giving majority of movies different variations of a Matinee (low matinee, high matinee) and for being very passionate. He has a strong distaste for "black foolishness" and boasts an exuberant and dramatic personality. A running gag involves his bizarre childhood, his head shape, his strange ability to make very peculiar friends, and how his dead father would react to him today. Korey has an alter-ego dubbed Korey-Bot, a robot puppet who is more rude and impolite than him.|
|Martin Thomas||Co-Host on The Sunday Service, The Weekly Roast and Toast and The Movie Review Extravaganza. Animator. Film Critic. Also known as Cat Daddy Thomas. Being older than Korey, he has a more intuitive look into things. He is sometimes harsher on films than Korey which leads to disagreements between the two. He is constantly the butt of jokes with his unusual stories (such as when he killed a turtle), his tastes and loves to make bad puns. He is a major comic book fan and is knowledgeable with superheroes.|
|Oswald "Oz" Green Jr.||Co-host on What Up Son. He interacts with the crew on a webcam from New York City. He is jovial and friendly and loves blasting "black foolishness" with Korey.|
|Merve "Mia" Coleman||Co-host on What Up Son and occasional co-host on various shows. She is from Turkey and she is also the wife of Korey Coleman. While not as seasoned due to her upbringing, she can make a conversation interesting and occasionally brings very intuitive insight. Despite being Korey Coleman's wife, they still sometimes refer to her as "Miss Mia."|
|Christopher "Juicy" Herman||Co-Host on The Sunday Service and 8-Bit Crumbs. He's known for his amicable personality on and off camera. He tends to have very staunch opinions on film and television that sometimes clash with the rest of the crew. A running gag involves his lack of knowledge regarding music.|
|Billy Brooks||Co-host on The Weekly Roast and Toast. His brother is actor Mehcad Brooks and his father is former American football wide receiver Billy Brooks. He has a wild and eccentric personality and is famous for his laugh dubbed "The Billy Cackle". A running gag would involve Korey attempting to have Billy give into his notorious laugh by showing him an unintentionally humorous moment in a bad film. He is sometimes more observant than Korey.|
|Tony "Sidekick 3000" Guerrero||Co-host only appears during special holidays (mostly Halloween shows) and event shows. He is usually depicted as a flying robotic toaster, typically opposite Korey. He was originally known as Co-Host 3000 on Spill.com. He has appeared without the robot animation once on the Resident Evil 2 playthrough episode. He is also an actor and as appeared in Alita: Battle Angel as an angry Mexican henchman, and in the indie film Woods Porn. His favorite bands are Cannibal Corpse and Faith No More.|
Former co-hosts include:
- Tommy McGrew – The first regular co-host to be added to the show after the closing of Spill.com. McGrew has not appeared on the site since 2016 when he was involved in a fatal hit and run accident, killing a pedestrian. Besides the initial update to Tommy's situation in mid 2016, Korey Coleman, and the rest of the Double Toasted crew have refrained from mentioning his name on the site. Korey has stated once, after getting many emails about Tommy's return to the site, that the chances of McGrew returning to the site is highly unlikely. However, Tommy made a surprise appearance on a February 2019 show where he revealed that he is on probation for ten years and had to seek therapy. He has expressed interest in returning, but Korey confirmed that it would be impossible.
- Patrick Girts – Former co-host on the High Score, The Movie Review Extravaganza and The Weekly Roast and Toast. Girts chose to leave due to the stresses of working on three shows late at night and wanting to focus on a career in marketing. He still makes occasional appearances.
- Danielle Dallaire – Former co-host on What Up Son and occasionally co-hosted on various shows. She left to pursue other opportunities. Though Danielle had initially claimed that it would only be for a year, Korey Coleman has openly doubted it with Danielle confirming that it was a long term job. Her final show was on May 14, 2018. In mid-2021, Danielle returned, seemingly as a regular and began to appear more often. On November 9, 2021, Korey announced that he banned her from the show due to her behavior.
- Korey Goodwin – Former host of The High Score and co-host on The Weekly Roast and Toast and The Movie Review Extravaganza. He can speak Mandarin. His final show was on June 13, 2018. He left to go focus on his own personal career. He still makes occasional appearances.
- Sam "Sammy" González – Former editor and regulator of the fan pages. Host on Sammy Ain't Seen Sh*t. Occasional co-host on various shows. He left to pursue other interests. His final show was on April 28, 2019. He still makes occasional appearances.
- Ian Butcher – Former co-host on Sammy Ain't Seen Sh*t and Toast to Toast.
- Taylor "Kung-Fu T.J." Manatsa – Former co-host on The High Score. He still makes occasional appearances, but mostly as an audience member.
- Chase Arthur – Former co-host of the Double Dribble.
- Ray Villareal – Also known as rapper "Tone Royal", former co-host of the Double Dribble. He still makes occasional appearances.
- William Valle – Former editor and contributor for the site. Occasional co-host on various shows. He talked about controversial topics. He still makes occasional appearances.
- Shea Young – The first female cast member added to the site. Shea left in February 2016 to pursue other opportunities, and because of negative fan reaction to her. She is the only former member who have not made an appearance after leaving the site.
- Robert "DJ Milez" Araya – Former co-host on What's in the Box.
- Christian Torres - Former Co-host on The Daily Double Talk, former co-host on What's in the Box. Author of comic, Here We Are Lost.
Awards and recognition
- "Double Toasted: Movie Reviews - Podcasting - Shows - Comedy - Gaming". Double Toasted.
- Gallaga, Omar (2015-01-27). "Statesman Shots #50: Martin Thomas on Double Toasted's origin story". Austin American Statesman (Podcast).
- Double Toasted (2015-11-15), STEVE-O - Double Toasted Interview, retrieved 2016-09-07
- Double Toasted (2016-04-22), EXCLUSIVE! DR. STRANGE WRITER "C. ROBERT CARGILL" - Double Toasted Interview, retrieved 2016-09-07
- Double Toasted (2015-12-16), BLACK NERD COMEDY - Double Toasted Interview, retrieved 2016-09-07
- Double Toasted (2016-09-11), The Sunday Service – 9-11-16 - Mattress Store Mocks 9/11, retrieved 2017-05-22
- "The Sunday Service LIVE @ 5:30 PM CST | PANDEMIC MOVIES, BAD CORONAVIRUS ADVICE AND MORE!". Double Toasted. March 15, 2020.
- "ALAN HOFMANIS INTERVIEW – What Up, Son?! LIVE @ 9:30 PM CST". Double Toasted. July 8, 2019.
- Coleman, Korey (July 16, 2019). "The Weekly Roast and Toast LIVE @ 9:15 PM CST". Double Toasted. Retrieved July 17, 2019.
- "Panacea - Revolution World Crazy (Hip Hop) (2010)". YouTube. foreal1992. October 2, 2019.
- "DT INTERVIEW – The Gentleman Driver". Double Toasted. February 1, 2019.
- "INTERVIEW – MARY LYNN RAJSKUB". Double Toasted. April 25, 2019.
- "INTERVIEW – STEVE JOHNSON". Double Toasted. June 14, 2019.
- "XAVIER BURGIN – INTERVIEW". Double Toasted. July 5, 2019.
- "LISA HENSON INTERVIEW". Double Toasted. August 6, 2019.
- "Jhonen Vasquez Interview LIVE @ 4:00 PM CST". Double Toasted. August 22, 2019.
- "KEITH DAVID INTERVIEW". Double Toasted. August 27, 2019.
- "DOUBLE TOASTED INTERVIEW - Alexandre O. Philippe, Director of 'Memory: The Origin of Alien'". Twitch. October 24, 2019.
- "DOUBLE TOASTED INTERVIEW: WILLIAM CONLIN - Director of the documentary 'Making Apes: The Artist Who Changed Film'". Twitch. October 26, 2019.
- "DOUBLE TOASTED INTERVIEW: ANDREW SHEA - Director of one of our favorite movies of all time 'The Corndog Man'". Twitch. November 15, 2019.
- "Sergio Pablos Interview". Double Toasted. January 9, 2020.
- "Sam Sawyer Interview". Double Toasted. January 10, 2020.
- "Jerry Minor Interview". Double Toasted. January 17, 2020.
- "DT INTERVIEW: ROB PAULSON". Twitch. January 23, 2020.
- "BRUCE W. SMITH Interview". Double Toasted. February 4, 2020.
- "J.D. WITHERSPOON – DT Interview". Double Toasted. March 26, 2020.
- "CHRIS STUCKMANN INTERVIEW | Double Toasted" (Video). YouTube.com. 9 January 2021. Retrieved 12 April 2021.
- DOUG WALKER (NOSTALGIA CRITIC) INTERVIEW | Double Toasted, retrieved 2022-02-13
- Jechow, Andy (16 February 2016). "Driver returned to scene of January hit-and-run, denied involvement".
- "The Sunday Service LIVE – 3:15 pm CST". Double Toasted. February 3, 2019.
- Coleman, Korey (April 28, 2019). "The Sunday Service LIVE – 5:30 pm CST". Double Toasted. Retrieved April 28, 2019.
- Coleman, Korey (May 14, 2018). "BlacKkKlansman Trailer Review - Safari Cheetahs Chase Family - What Up, Son?!". Double Toasted. Retrieved May 14, 2018.
- Coleman, Korey (June 13, 2018). "The Movie Review Extravaganza - Tag and Superfly Review". Double Toasted. Retrieved June 13, 2018.
- "Family Feud Player and the Mommy Incident". doubletoasted.com.
- "Double Toasted - Best Podcast - Best of Austin - 2015 - Readers - Media - The Austin Chronicle". www.austinchronicle.com. Retrieved 2016-09-09.