|Formerly||WebTV (September 1996 - April 1997)|
Microsoft WebTV (April 1997 - July 2001)
|Type||Wholly owned subsidiary|
|Defunct||September 30, 2013|
Number of employees
MSN TV (formerly WebTV) was a web access product consisting of a thin client device which used a television for display (instead of using a computer monitor), and the online service that supported it. The device design and service was developed by WebTV Networks, Inc., a company started in 1995. The WebTV product was announced in July 1996 and later released on September 18, 1996. In April 1997, the company was purchased by Microsoft Corporation and in July of 2001, was absorbed into MSN (the Microsoft Network).
The WebTV and MSN TV devices allowed a television set to be connected to the Internet, mainly for web browsing and e-mail. The WebTV/MSN TV service however also offered its own exclusive services such as a "walled garden" newsgroup service, news and weather reports, storage for user bookmarks (Favorites), IRC (and for a time, MSN Chat) chatrooms, a Page Builder service that let WebTV users create and host webpages that could later be shared to others via a link if desired, dedicated sections for aggregated content covering various topics (entertainment, romance, stocks, etc.), and a few years after Microsoft bought out WebTV, integration with MSN Messenger and Hotmail. The setup included a thin client in the form of a set-top box, a remote, a network connection using dial-up, or with the introduction of Rogers Interactive TV and the MSNTV 2, the option to use broadband, and a wireless keyboard, which was sold optionally up until the 2000s.
Although WebTV allowed less functionality than a standard computer-based web browser, it was a low-cost alternative to a traditional computer connection to the Internet.
The WebTV/MSN TV service lasted for 17 years, shutting down on September 30, 2013 and allowing subscribers to migrate their data well before that date arrived.
The original WebTV network relied on a Solaris backend network and telephone lines to deliver service to customers via dial-up, with "frontend servers" that talk directly to boxes using a custom protocol, the WebTV Protocol (WTVP), to authenticate users and deliver content to boxes. For the MSNTV 2, however, a completely new service based on IIS servers and regular HTTP/HTTPS services was used.
I've been working to create an interactive television my entire life. I always knew it was a way of bringing computers to average people.— Steve Perlman
Co-founder Steve Perlman is credited with the idea for the device. He first combined computer and television as a high-school student when he decided his home PC needed a graphics display. He went on to build software for companies such as Apple and Atari. While working at General Magic, the idea of bringing TVs and computers together resurfaced.
One night, Perlman was browsing the web and came across a Campbell's soup website with recipes. He thought that the people who might be interested in what the site had to offer were not using the web. It occurred to him that if the television audience was enabled by a device to augment television viewing with receiving information or commercial offers through the television, then perhaps the web address could act as a signal and the television cable could be the conduit.
A Silicon Valley startup, WebTV Networks was founded in July 1995. Perlman brought along co-founders Bruce Leak and Phil Goldman shortly after conceiving the basic concept. The company operated out of half of a former BMW car dealership building on Alma Street in Palo Alto, California, which was being used for storage by the Museum of American Heritage. WebTV had been able to obtain the space for very low rent, but it was suboptimal for technology development.
Before incorporation, the company referred to itself as Artemis Research to disguise the nature of its business. The info page of its original website explained that it was studying "sleep deprivation, poor diet and no social life for extended periods on humans and dwarf rabbits". The dwarf rabbit reference was an inside joke among WebTV's hard-working engineers—Phil Goldman's pet house rabbit Bowser (inspiration for the General Magic logo) was often found roaming the WebTV building late into the night while the engineers were working—although WebTV actually received inquiries from real research groups conducting similar studies and seeking to exchange data.
The company hired many engineers and a few business development employees early on, having about 30 total employees by October 1995. Two early employees of Artemis were from Apple Inc: Andy Rubin, creator of the Android cell phone OS, and Joe Britt. Both men would later be two of the founders of Danger, Inc. (originally Danger Research).
WebTV Networks' business model was to license a reference design to consumer electronics companies for a WebTV Internet Terminal, a set-top box that attached to a telephone line and automatically connected to the Internet through a dial-up modem. The consumer electronics companies' income was derived from selling the WebTV set-top box. WebTV's income was derived from operating the WebTV Service, the Internet-based service to which the set-top boxes connected and for which it collected a fee from WebTV subscribers. The service provided features such as HTML-based email, and proxied websites, which were reformatted by the service before they were sent to set-top box, to make them display more efficiently on a television screen.
WebTV closed its first round of financing, US$1,500,000, from Marvin Davis in September 1995, which it used to develop its prototype set-top box, using proprietary hardware and firmware. The company also used the financing to develop the online service that the set-top boxes connected to. WebTV leveraged their limited startup funds by licensing a reference design for the appliance to Sony and Philips. Eventually other companies would also become licensees and WebTV would profit on the monthly service fees. After 22 months, the company was sold to Microsoft for $425 million, with each of the three founders receiving $64 million.
Barely surviving to reach announcement
By the spring of 1996 WebTV Networks employed approximately 70 people, many of them finishing their senior year at nearby Stanford University, or former employees of either Apple Computer or General Magic. WebTV had started negotiating with Sony to manufacture and distribute the WebTV set-top box, but negotiations had taken much longer than WebTV had expected, and WebTV had used up its initial funding. Steve Perlman liquidated his assets, ran up his credit cards and mortgaged his house to provide bridge financing while seeking additional venture capital. Because Sony had insisted upon exclusive distribution rights for the first year, WebTV had no other distribution partner in place, and just before WebTV was to close venture capital financing from Brentwood Associates, Sony sent WebTV a certified letter stating it had decided not to proceed with WebTV. It was a critical juncture for WebTV, because the Brentwood financing had been predicated on the expectation of a future relationship with Sony, and if Brentwood had decided to not proceed with the financing after being told that Sony had backed out, WebTV would have gone bankrupt and Perlman would have lost everything. But Brentwood decided to proceed with the financing despite losing Sony's involvement, and further financing from Paul Allen's Vulcan Ventures soon followed.
WebTV then proceeded to close a non-exclusive WebTV set-top box distribution deal with Philips, which provided competitive pressure causing Sony to change its mind, to resume its relationship with WebTV and also to distribute WebTV.
WebTV was announced on July 10, 1996, generating a large wave of press attention as not only the first television-based use of the World Wide Web, but also as the first consumer-electronics device to access the World Wide Web without a personal computer. After the product's announcement, the company closed additional venture financing, including investments from Microsoft Corporation, Citicorp, Seagate Technology, Inc., Soros Capital, L.P., St. Paul Venture Capital and Times Mirror Company.
WebTV was launched on September 18, 1996, within one year after its first round of financing, with WebTV set-top boxes in stores from Sony and Philips, and WebTV's online service running from servers in its tiny office, still based in the former BMW dealership.
The initial price for the WebTV set-top box was US$349 for the Sony version and US$329 for the Philips version, with a wireless keyboard available for about an extra US$50. The monthly service fee initially was US$19.95 per month for unlimited Web surfing and e-mail.
There was little difference between the first Sony and the Philips WebTV set-top boxes, except for the housing and packaging. The WebTV set-top box had very limited processing and memory resources (just a 112 MHz MIPS CPU, 2 megabytes of RAM, 2 megabytes of ROM, 1 megabyte of Flash memory) and the device relied upon a connection through a 33.6 kbit/s dialup modem to connect to the WebTV Service, where powerful servers provide back-end support to the WebTV set-top boxes to support a full Web-browsing and email experience for the subscribers.
Initial sales were slow. By April 1997, WebTV had only 56,000 subscribers, but the pace of subscriber growth accelerated after that, achieving 150,000 subscribers by Autumn 1997, about 325,000 subscribers by April 1998 and about 800,000 subscribers by May 1999. WebTV achieved profitability by Spring 1998, and grossed over US$1.3 billion in revenue through its first 8 years of operation. In 2005 WebTV was still grossing US$150 million per year in revenue with 65% gross margin.
WebTV briefly classified as a weapon
Because WebTV utilized strong encryption, upon launch in 1996, WebTV was classified as munitions (a military weapon) by the United States government and was therefore barred from export under United States security laws at the time. Because WebTV was widely distributed in consumer electronic stores under the Sony and Philips brands for only US$325, its munitions classification was used to argue that the US should no longer consider devices incorporating strong encryption to be munitions, and should permit their export. WebTV obtained a special exemption permitting its export, despite the strong encryption, and shortly thereafter, laws concerning export of cryptography in the United States were changed to generally permit the export of strong encryption.
Microsoft takes notice
In February 1997, in an investor meeting with Microsoft, Steve Perlman was approached by Microsoft's Senior Vice President for Consumer Platforms Division, Craig Mundie. Despite the fact that the initial WebTV sales had been modest, Mundie expressed that Microsoft was impressed with WebTV and saw significant potential both in WebTV's product offering and in applying the technology to other Microsoft consumer and video product offerings. Microsoft offered to acquire WebTV, build a Microsoft campus in Silicon Valley around WebTV, and establish WebTV as a Microsoft division to develop television-based products and services, with Perlman as the division's president.
Discussions proceeded rapidly, involving Bill Gates, then CEO of Microsoft, personally. Gates called Perlman at his home on Easter Sunday in March 1997, and Perlman described to Gates WebTV's next generation products in development, which would be the first consumer devices to incorporate hard disks, including the WebTV Plus, and the WebTV Digital Video Recorders. Gates' interest was piqued, and negotiations between Microsoft and WebTV rapidly proceeded to closure, with both sides working around the clock to get the deal done. Negotiation time was so short that the hour lost due to the change to Daylight Saving Time the night before the planned announcement, which the parties had neglected to factor into their schedule, almost left them without enough time to finish the deal.
On April 6, 1997, 20 months after WebTV's founding, and only six weeks after negotiations with Microsoft began, during a scheduled speech at the National Association of Broadcasters conference in Las Vegas, Nevada, Craig Mundie announced that Microsoft had acquired WebTV. The acquisition price was US$503 million, but WebTV was so young a company that most of the employees' stock options had yet to be vested. As such, the vested shares at the time of the announcement amounted to US$425 million, and that was the acquisition price announced.
Subsequent to the acquisition, WebTV became a Silicon Valley-based division of Microsoft, with Steve Perlman as its president. The WebTV division began developing most of Microsoft's television-based products, including the first satellite Digital Video Recorders (the DishPlayer for EchoStar's Dish Network and UltimateTV for DirecTV), Microsoft's cable TV products, the Xbox 360 hardware, and Microsoft's Mediaroom IPTV platform.
MSN TV rebranding
In July 2001, six years after WebTV's founding, Microsoft rebranded WebTV as MSN TV. Contracts were terminated with all other licensed manufacturers of the WebTV hardware except RCA, leaving them as the sole manufacturer of further hardware. Promotion of the WebTV brand ended.
In later years, the number of consumers using dialup access had dropped and as the Classic and Plus clients were restricted to dialup access, their subscriber count began to drop. Because the WebTV client was subsidized hardware, the company had always required individual subscriptions for each box, but with the subsidies ended, MSN started offering free use of MSN TV boxes to their computer users who subscribed to MSN as an incentive not to depart for discount dialup ISPs.
Broadband MSN TV
In 2001, Rogers Cable partnered with Microsoft to introduce "Rogers Interactive TV" in Canada. The service enabled Rogers' subscribers to access the Web via their TV sets, create their own websites, shop online, chat, and access e-mail. This initiative was the first broadband implementation of MSN TV.
In late 2004, Microsoft introduced MSNTV 2. Codenamed the "Deuce", it was capable of broadband access, introduced a revamped user interface and new capabilities such as offline viewing of media, audio and video streaming (broadband only), and even allowed the use of a mouse.
For inexpensive devices, the cost of licensing the operating system is substantial. For Microsoft, however, it would be actualizing a sunk cost, and when Microsoft released the MSNTV 2 model, they adopted standard PC architecture and used Windows CE software with few changes. This allowed a standard PC to be used with relatively few changes, allowing MSNTV 2 to more easily and inexpensively keep current. The new box had Adobe Reader, Windows Media Player, and could access Windows computers on a home network to function as a media player. MSNTV 2 used a different online service from MSN TV but, like WebTV, still required a subscription. For those with broadband, the fee was US$99 yearly.
By 2010, MSN TV hardware was no longer being manufactured and sold by Microsoft, although service continued for existing users for the next three years. Attempting to go to the "Buy MSN TV" section on the MSN TV website at the time resulted in the following message being shown:
"Sorry, MSN TV hardware is no longer available for purchase from Microsoft. Microsoft continues to support the subscription service for existing WebTV and MSN TV customers."
On July 1, 2013, an email was sent out to subscribers stating that the MSN TV service would be shutting down on September 30, 2013. During that time, subscribers were advised to convert any accounts on the first-generation service to Microsoft accounts and to migrate any favorites and other data they had on their MSN TV accounts to SkyDrive. Once September 30, 2013 finally arrived, the WebTV/MSN TV service fully closed. Existing customers were offered MSN Dial-Up Internet Access accounts with a promotion. Customer service was available for non-technical and billing questions until January 15, 2014.
Since the WebTV set-top box was a dedicated web-browsing appliance that did not need to be based on a standard operating system, the cost of licensing an operating system could be avoided. All first generation boxes featured a 64-bit MIPS RISC CPU, boot ROM and flash ROM storage for all Classic and New Plus models, RAM, and a smart card reader, which wasn't significantly utilized. The web browser that ran on the set-top box was compatible with both Netscape Navigator and Microsoft Internet Explorer standards. The first WebTV Classic set-top boxes from Sony and Philips had a 33.6k modem, and 2 MB of RAM, boot ROM, and flash ROM. Later models had 56k modems and increased ROM/RAM capacity. The WebTV set-top boxes leveraged the service's server-side caching proxy which reformatted and compressed web pages before sending them to the box, a feature generally unavailable to dial-up ISP users at the time and as such, had to be developed by WebTV. For web browsing purposes, given WebTV's thin client software, there was no need for a hard disk, but by putting the browser in non-volatile memory, upgrades could be downloaded from the WebTV service onto the set-top box.
The WebTV set-top box was designed so that at a specified time, it would check to see if there was any email waiting. If there was, it would illuminate a red LED on the device so the consumer would know it was worth connecting to pick up their mail.
A second model, the "Plus", was introduced a year later. This model featured RF and composite inputs to allow watching television in a PIP (Picture-In-Picture) window, allowed one to capture video stills from said inputs as a JPEG and offered the options to upload the captures to a WebTV discussion post, email, or a "scrapbook" on a user's account for later use, and included a video tuner that allowed one to schedule a VCR in a manner like TiVo allowed several years later. The Plus also included a 56k modem. In order to accommodate large nightly downloads of television schedules, a hard drive was included in the original Plus. Around Fall 1998, plans for a "Derby" revision of the WebTV Plus were announced, which claimed to have a faster CPU and more memory. By early 1999, only one Derby unit was produced by Sony as a revision of their INT-W200 Plus model, and while the CPU speed was increased by a small amount, no increase in memory had been found and the overall changes were negligant. As chip prices dropped, later versions of the Plus used an M-Systems DiskOnChip flashrom chip instead, alongside increasing RAM capacity to 16 MB. WebTV Plus also supported ATVEF, a technology that allowed users to download special script-laden pages to interact with television shows.
WebTV produced reference designs of models incorporating a disk-based personal video recorder and a satellite tuner for EchoStar's Dish Network (referred to as the DishPlayer) and for DirecTV (called UltimateTV). In 2001, EchoStar sued Microsoft for failing to support the WebTV DishPlayer. EchoStar subsequently sought to acquire DirecTV and was the presumptive acquirer, but EchoStar was ultimately blocked by the Federal Communications Commission. While EchoStar's lawsuit against Microsoft was in process, DirecTV (presumptively acquired and controlled by EchoStar) dropped UltimateTV (thus ending Microsoft's satellite product initiatives) and picked TiVo's DirecTV product as its only Digital Video Recorder offering.
As an ease-of-use design consideration, WebTV early decided to reformat pages rather than have users doing sideways scrolling. As entry-level PCs evolved from VGA resolution of 640x480 to SVGA resolution of 800x600, and web site dimensions followed suit, reformatting the PC-sized web pages to fit the 560-pixel width of a United States NTSC television screen became less satisfactory. The WebTV browser also translated HTML frames as tables in order to avoid the need for a mouse. To address these problems, the engineers at WebTV developed the MSN Companion, which was another easy-to-use thin client which used an SVGA monitor and mouse. Both Compaq and e-Machines marketed the Companion, Compaq producing it in multiple models. However, being substantially more expensive than WebTV (which at this time was typically $50 after rebate) and lacking many features that PC users and WebTV users found standard, the Companion never found a customer base.
In Japan, WebTV had a small run starting in around 1998, with a couple Japanese units being released with hard drives and two times more RAM than Classic and Old Plus units at the time, and in Spring of 1999, allowed customers to choose the option of utilizing Sega's Dreamcast video game console, which came with a built-in modem, to access WebTV. This was possible as Sega and Microsoft collaborated to create a port of the WebTV technology on the Dreamcast, using the Windows CE abstraction layer supported on the console and what's believed to be a version of the Internet Explorer 2.0 browser engine.
With the first generation of the WebTV/MSN TV service, it appears that a few protocols were used to allow communication with the service, but the main important one was WTVP, or the WebTV Protocol. It was a TCP-based protocol that was essentially a proprietary version of HTTP 1.0 that served service content to WebTV users and introduced its own extensions which include but aren't limited to message encryption, ticket-based authorization, proprietary authentication methods for logging in to the service, and persistent connections. This protocol was supported by all first-generation WebTV/MSN TV devices and the Sega Dreamcast release of WebTV up until the September 2013 discontinuation of the entire service. Another protocol believed to have been used by the service is dubbed "Mail Notify" and is believed to have taken part of delivering e-mail notifications to WebTV boxes. Its existence has only been confirmed in a leaked Microsoft document and how it operated or whether it was used on the client-side or as a server-side component isn't clear at the moment. WTVP had extremely minimal documentation back in WebTV's prime and only by 2019 did more attempts to document it crop up, although not by much initially. In general, it has been proven difficult to find WebTV staff who remember any more technical details on the protocol, let alone find any who have contact information at all, and WebTV hacking scene members who know how the protocols work (which generally speaking is very few people) have been hesitant to release any more significant information on them when asked. As of 2021, there has been an attempt to further explore the WTVP protocol in a more detailed and concise fashion along with other technical parts of WebTV/MSN TV by someone outside WebTV staff and its hacking scene, but with the lack of sufficient resources on any technical WebTV information and a lack of people with enough knowledge to reverse engineer how the service worked and share their findings publicly, progress on overall documentation on these protocols has been very slow.
The MSNTV 2's service was completely separate from the original one and ran on completely different infrastructure. It, like the first generation service's protocols, have next to no documentation available publicly. From what little information was disclosed by hackers, the service ran on IIS servers and used HTTP/HTTPS web services to communicate with boxes. It's also believed XML was one of the formats used by MSNTV 2's "protocol" although this cannot be 100% confirmed.
WebTV/MSN TV client hardware
|Brand||Model||Type||Modem||RAM||ROM||Storage||CPU speed||CPU chip||Latest Software Version|
|Sony||INT-W100||Classic||V.34||2 MB (2 MiB)||2 MB (2 MiB)||2 MB||112 MHz||R4640||126.96.36.199mpeg |
|Philips||MAT-960||Classic||V.34||2 MB||2 MB||2 MB||112 MHz||R4640||188.8.131.52mpeg |
|Sony||INT-WJ200||Classic (Japan)||V.90||8 MB||4 MB||1.1 GB||150 MHz||R4640|
|Sony||INT-W150||New Classic||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||2 MB||150 MHz||RM5230||2.9.1|
|Philips||MAT-965||New Classic||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||2 MB||150 MHz||RM5230||2.9.1|
|RCA||RW-2100||New Classic||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||2 MB||150 MHz||RM5230||2.9.1|
|Sony||INT-W200||Plus||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||1.1 GB||150 MHz||R4640||2.9.1|
|Sony||INT-W200B||Derby Plus||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||1.1 GB||167 MHz||RM5230|
|Philips||MAT-972||Plus||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||1.1 GB||150 MHz||R4640||2.9.1|
|Samsung||SIS-100||Plus||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||1.1 GB||150 MHz||R4640||2.9.1|
|Mitsubishi||RW-2000||Plus||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||1.1 GB||150 MHz||R4640||2.9.1|
|Mitsubishi||RW-2001||Plus||V.90||8 MB||2 MB||1.1 GB||150 MHz||R4640||2.9.1|
|Sony||INT-WJ300||Plus (Japan)||V.90||16 MB||4 MB||1.1 GB||167 MHz||RM5230|
|RCA||RW-2110||New Plus||V.90||16 MB||8 MB||2 MB||167 MHz||RM5230||2.9.1|
|Sony||INT-W250||New Plus||V.90||16 MB||8 MB||2 MB||167 MHz||RM5230||2.9.1|
|Philips||MAT-976||New Plus||V.90||16 MB||8 MB||2 MB||167 MHz||RM5230||2.9.1|
|Echostar||Dishplayer 7100||DISH tuner||V.90||16 MB||4 MB||8.6 GB||167 MHz||RM5230|
|Echostar||Dishplayer 7200||DISH tuner||V.90||16 MB||4 MB||17.6 GB||167 MHz||RM5230|
|RCA||UltimateTV||DirecTV tuner||V.90||16 MB||4 MB||40 GB||167 MHz||RM5230|
|RCA||RM-4100||MSNTV2||V.90||128 MB||none||64 MB||733 MHz||Celeron|
|RCA||RM-4100 (2)||MSNTV2||V.90||256 MB||none||64 MB||733 MHz||Celeron|
In February 2006, Chris Wade analyzed the proprietary BIOS of the MSNTV 2, and added a sophisticated memory patch which allowed it to be flashed and used to boot Linux on the MSNTV 2 player. An open-source solution to enabling TV output on the MSNTV 2 and similar devices was made available in 2009. Outside of these attempts, though, not much was done in the realm of hacking the WebTV/MSN TV hardware.
- Cade Metz. "25 Years of PC Magazine: Year Fifteen 1996." July 11, 2007
- Fortgang, Ron S.; Sebenius, James K. (1999-04-19), "Steve Perlman and WebTV (A & B)", Harvard Business Review
- Hof, Robert D. (1997-03-24), "WebTV: Hello, Couch Potatoes", BusinessWeek
- Artemis Research, archived from the original on January 31, 2014, retrieved 22 December 2015
- Wildstrom, Stephen H. (1996-09-16), "A Web-surfing Box for Peanuts", BusinessWeek
- Wallack, Todd (2003-12-30). "Phil Goldman -- entrepreneur, WebTV founder". December 30, 2003 : San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved 2006-12-08.
- Livingston, Jessica (2007), Founders at Work: Stories of Startups Early Days, Academic Press, pp. 173–90
- "Form S-4 Registration Statement, Registrants Microsoft Corporation and WebTV Networks, Inc.", Securities and Exchange Commission, 1997-05-02
- Metz, Cade (2007-07-11), "25 Years of PC Magazine: Year Fifteen – 1996", PC Magazine
- Mundie, Craig (1998-04-07), "National Association of Broadcasters Conference" (speech transcript), Presspass, Microsoft
- "WebTV Networks Launches Next-Generation WebTV Classic and Plus Products; Provides Free Service Upgrade" (press release), Presspass, Microsoft, 1999-06-02
- Richtel, Matt (1999-05-12), "America Online Challenges Microsoft's WebTV", New York Times
- Markoff, John (1996-11-08), "U.S. Classifies a Device to Surf the Web as a Weapon", New York Times
- "Steve Perlman Biography". Rearden. Retrieved 2009-12-20.
- Takahashi, Dean (2006), The Xbox 360 Uncloaked: The Real Story Behind Microsoft's Next-Generation Video Game Console, SpiderWorks/Lulu Press, pp. 60–69, ISBN 0-9777842-1-5
- "WebTV Internet Service Renamed MSN TV Service" (press release), Presspass, Microsoft, 2001-07-18
- MSN TV: Buy MSN TV, archived from the original on 2010-03-24
- MSN TV: Closure FAQ Archived 2013-07-09 at the Wayback Machine. Webtv.com. Retrieved on 2013-08-23.
- "The DishPlayer Experience", Voice, Net4TV
- "RCA's Personal TV Play", Voice, Net4TV
- Chart beat bonus, Billboard, archived from the original on November 3, 2012
- EchoStar's DirecTV bid blocked by FCC, MarketWatch
- "WebTV for Dreamcast - Sega Retro".
- "WebTV'er MattMan69 TOS'ed For Secret Pics," April 11, 1999, Net4TV Voice. Retrieved 2013-08-13.
- WTVP - WebTV/MSN TV Wiki
- Msntv2 Linux port, archived from the original on 2011-09-21
- Set-Top-Linux, archived from the original on 2009-07-31
- MSN TV, Microsoft, archived from the original on 2013-01-11CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link) (archive.is).
- GNU/Linux on the MSN TV 2, toc2rta, archived from the original on 2007-06-24, retrieved 2020-03-21.
- MSN TV 2 Internet & Media Player (review), The gadgeteer
- "WebTV/MSNTV Upgrades", Nytak (list), Tripod